The Influence of Machiavelli on Shakespeare's Plays The Italian Renaissance-era philosopher and political adviser Nicolo Machiavelli is one of the most famous and infamous writers on the subject of politics.
Is Macbeth a Machiavellian leader? Some people say that Macbeth is a Machiavellian ruler. Others qualify him saying that he holds certain Machiavellian traits but not all. We will write a custom essay sample on Is Macbeth a Machiavellian leader? Despite possessing these Machiavellian qualities, Macbeth is not a true Machiavellian leader.
The other characters lose all trust and respect for Macbeth. The people of Scotland look up to Macbeth. The people of Scotland trusts Macbeth to run their country well, but in the end he runs it into the ground, forcing them into poverty and misfortune.
Macbeth never keeps his people satisfied, but rather he does things to make them extremely displeased. He lets the prophecies control all his actions and decisions from that point on, which leads to his downfall. Not only does Macbeth let the prophecies control his every action, but he also lets his wife, Lady Macbeth, make all his decisions for him.
She drives him to kill Duncan to achieve the thrown. When he questions her direction she outraged, calls him a coward and questions his manhood: She makes him the power hungry tyrant he ultimately becomes. Macbeth takes the heir to the throne which should not have been his. He also achieves the throne by treacherous means.
He never makes his own plan; he uses the prophecies as his plan. Macbeth lets too many outside characters affect his decisions, feelings and actions; something a true Machiavellian leader would never do.
To a true and successful ruler, war is the number one priority. In act four scene one, the three witches see three apparitions and earn Macbeth not to ask about them. After the death of Duncan, Malcolm and Macduff begin planning their attack on Macbeth, while Macbeth worries about obtaining more power.
He realizes in that moment, that he will be defeated. He has no army to fight with, and no plan. Because he is unprepared, he loses his life to Macduff.
Macbeth never once worries about or prepares for war, instead he spent his time fixating on other things, which leads to his defeat.
Outstanding rulers take on great conquests and inspire others by their noble actions. Macbeth thinks he will be a great ruler of the throne, and he will have great affairs, but he does nothing of greatness or goodness. He does nothing for them that a good ruler should. In The Prince, Machiavelli says that a good ruler should show that he loves talent and rewards it, encourage his citizens to prosper in their occupations, keep the people entertained with festivals when appropriate, and he should give attention to the various civic groups without appearing undignified; none of which Macbeth did.
Macbeth never proves himself to his people. He never does anything extraordinary. Machiavelli gives the Spain of Ferdinand as an example; he did various things to distract his people from overthrowing him such as; attacking Granada, driving the Moors out of Spain, and attacking Africa, Italy, and France.
Macbeth never does anything to keep his people from overthrowing him, he is too infatuated with gaining power to worry about anything else. A prince should always be ready to take a side—Macbeth flip flops to whichever side benefits him at that moment.
He only says this so he can lure Duncan into trusting him, so he can murder Duncan. He and Banquo build a relationship full of trust. Not only did Macbeth fail to choose sides, but he also goes against people much more powerful than himself.
The witches warn Macbeth to fear Macduff, but Macbeth disregards their warnings — a decision he would come to regret. Macduff is much more powerful and prepared than Macbeth. Macbeth hardly takes a side, but when he does he never sticks to it.Essay about Macbeth and Machiavelli Comparison leader is one who knows the way, goes the way, and shows the way.” This quote shows how leadership has been interpreted differently through the years.
Shakespeare’s character Lady Macbeth followed Machiavelli’s rules in the supernatural play Macbeth.
Machiavelli's unsentimental and irreligious attitude towards kingship was very controversial at the time and influenced many of the depictions of villains in the Elizabethan playwright William Shakespeare's plays, including Julius Caesar, Macbeth and Richard III.
The Holy Bible: King James Version. Jeremiah 9. 1: Oh that my head were waters, and mine eyes a fountain of tears, that I might weep day and night for the slain of . An effective leader must not be moral to gain power.
In Macbeth, Lady Macbeth is shown to be a character who is controlling and does not worry about morals. She would be considered an effective leader by Machiavelli because loses her morality to get what she wishes.
H/T Robin Hanson: Aeon’s The Good Guy / Bad Guy Myth.. “Pop culture today is obsessed with the battle between good and evil.
. Shakespeare’s character Macbeth represents the Machiavellian idea that a ruler should appear well in public, be smart and strong, and do what is necessary to hold onto power. Shakespeare used imagery, and metaphors to portray Macbeth this way because, although he dies in the end, Macbeth still used Machiavelli’s ideals, and was successful in many ways.