Authors Co-authored with Sandi Roy, M.
Alice Miller in a Nutshell: A Brief Critique Posted on by dmackler58 [Written in late I have finally done so—and have gone in a few new directions too… Before I begin the new essay, I want to make a few background points.
I wrote the longer essay in A few months after I wrote it someone passed it along to Alice Miller herself, and she read it—and criticized it harshly on her website.
However, by putting my name on her website she generated a significant amount of attention for my essay, because within hours a horde of people googled my name, found the essay, and read it for themselves.
Several wrote me complimentary emails. She offered people an enlightened witness to their pain and horror, and confirmed what so many felt to be true: I feel she started a psychological revolution into the exploration of the causes and consequences of childhood traumas, and she set the bar several feet higher for the whole psychology field.
Why then is Alice Miller not more well-known in the psychology field? She avoids silly theories, she avoids confusing jargon, and she avoids making the hordes of irrelevant footnotes that so easily become the hallmark of small-mindedness. This begs the question of why people want to defend their parents.
And so many people, and the psychology field in general, are simply pain-avoidant, at all costs. Whole therapies and psychological theories and of course psychiatric medications are devoted to avoiding and bypassing the very pain, the necessary and healthy pain, that Alice Miller leads us right into.
As such, they dismiss Alice Miller. But how do they get away with dismissing her? In short, they attempt to render her irrelevant by ignoring her—with the most cruel tool of all: You say that her works repeat themselves?
She came up with one great idea, and then repeated it over and over with only slight variation. She originally wrote and published a version of that first chapter in the International Journal of Psychoanalysis, and then re-crafted it for publication in her book. Many of her books read like repeats of earlier books.
Well, to get the basic essence of her point of view. It also has a far-reaching philosophical and psychological point: She took a lot of heat for writing that chapter—especially since she is of Germanic origin and originally wrote it in German. Very politically incorrect stuff—yet vitally important.
So what is your criticism of her—what is your perspective? My main criticism is that Alice Miller does not adequately apply her point of view to herself—and does not take her point of view to its logical conclusion. Let me start again by stating her point of view as logically as I can: She points out that in most cases abusive parents are the essential cause of these conflicts.
This is the essence of the repetition compulsion, a Freudian concept which she respects highly. She fails to take her theories to the next appropriate level. And the next level is?
Throughout her work she gives her tacit approval to people to become parents—to have children—before they have healed their traumas. In this way she considers it inevitable that people will abuse their children.
And to me that is a major cop-out—and a major flaw in her logic—because it goes against her whole point of view.Feb 07, · How to Write a Critique in Five Paragraphs. A critique is usually written in response to a creative work, such as a novel, a film, poetry, or a painting.
However, critiques are also sometimes assigned for research articles and media items. Mar 26, · Every day there is some new technological advancement making its way into the world in an attempt to make life easier for people.
In the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”, author Nicholas Carr explains his thoughts on how he believes the internet is running the risk of making people full of artificial knowledge. In the UK, 2·85 million people (5·7% of adults) regularly use electronic cigarettes (ECs), almost all of whom are smokers or ex-smokers.1 Prevalence of EC use is similar in the USA2 but is lower in other European Union (EU) countries (average 2%).1 ECs produce an estimated 18 additional long-term ex-smokers in England each year;3 a recent update suggests that figure might be as high as.
Mar 21, · Fox News is a "propaganda machine." It is "wittingly harming our system of government for profit." Fox critics -- mostly on the left -- have been making arguments like these for years. TheINQUIRER publishes daily news, reviews on the latest gadgets and devices, and INQdepth articles for tech buffs and hobbyists.
About jamie Jamie is an award winning artist who has recently taken a hop, a skip, and a few jumps, and has landed happily in California.
She specializes in textile/fabric pieces (art that you wear), but also creates paintings, sculptures, and quilted works of art.